Skip to main content

Mercy Bar + Eatery (closed)

*This venue is now closed* 

I'd been looking forward to this dinner for a long time - not only for the company, but also because I was keen to try Mercy Bar + Eatery (31 Flinders Lane, Melbourne), formerly known as Virginia Plain (see my previous blog post here).


In its former state, I'd tried the degustation with matching wines and been quite impressed. Word on the street was that, although Mercy Bar is still run by the same crew (owned by Marco Santucci, with Andy Harmer as chef and Mat Beyer running front-of-house), it was revamping in response to what the people wanted: a more casual eatery, with a 'less austere' ambience. It's still a great venue, but I'm not sure it has hit its mark just yet.

Sure, it's a little more colourful, with street-style art by Steve Cross and touches of bright neon lighting, but I was expecting more bar, less eatery - well, less 'restaurant' style eatery, anyway. I was kinda disappointed to see that the restaurant's layout is much the same: long bar down one side, kitchen at the back (though I guess that's harder to move), plus what's basically a hall full of low dining tables (srsly, this place is MASSIVE). The only major layout change I could see was a few communal tables in the front section.

I gather that Mercy is a popular business lunch venue, being smack-bang in the middle of Melbourne's CBD foodie zone (the Paris end, naturally, dahhh-link). It claims to have loosened its menu, introducing more snack-style options, and is planning to offer more beers on tap (which it may well have already done - I don't drink beer, so I wouldn't have a clue. I did, however, enjoy a lovely lemon champagne cocktail on arrival - a French something-or-other).

Frenchie cocktail

For a second time upon this site, I ventured into degustation territory - only to find it a VERY similar experience to the Virginia Plain degustation. Everything was delicious, but it felt like history repeating: soup, fish, meat taster, dessert. Déjà vu! Perhaps I should have requested a mix of the new menu items - but one would expect the degustation to have changed somewhat, well over six months later and with a branding revamp.

I also found the wine matching very strange. First course was a French onion soup - the onions had been caramelised for three days, we were told. With this, came a strong, dry sherry, apparently to cut through the sweetness of the caramelised onion. Whaaaa?! I'm not a sherry fan at the best of times, but I gave it a shot. It was definitely better with the food, but I'm still not convinced it was the best drink to begin with. The other wines were more 'normal', but I still found them too diverse and too strong in general. Yes, I like to try new wines, but food-and-wine-matching is a delicate art and I think, Mercy, you might be trying a wee bit too hard in this regard.

French onion soup


Then followed a DELICIOUS terrine - although it was so soft, it was more like a pâté - and a fish dish, possibly cod (??) that was nice and foamy. The meat tasting platter was yummy, but basically the same as last time, and the dessert was a HUGE improvement on my previous experience of Banoffee Pie (I HATE bananas... yes HATE them): this time, a delicious chocolate sponge with pear mousse. Ohhhh baby yes. 

Terrine, NOM

One of the better wines, happily served in a massive glass

Fishy goodness

Tasting platter of pork belly (I think), bone marrow, wagyu steak, potato stack

Chocolate & pear dessert... although it looked like poo, it did not taste like poo

The main benefit of a degustation is that you don't have to think. We definitely took advantage of this, and concentrated on our catch-up. The waitstaff were delightful in general: fun and flirty, there when you wanted them to be and absent when you didn't, and describing each dish in enough detail to enjoy it, but not to be bored by their dissertation! Mercy Bar also has a fun social media presence - clearly, interaction with customers is one of its stronger points.

I came away from Mercy Bar having enjoyed my dinner, but a little disappointed that it wasn't as different as I'd hoped. It's a very large space - which, admittedly, would be difficult to rearrange or redecorate. Although it's funkier now, I don't feel it's quite dropped the 'austere' tag. I believe a reshuffle of the layout - perhaps filling it with more STUFF to make it feel more knick-knacky and therefore casual, or dividing it into smaller sections - would go a long way towards creating the vibe they are hoping for.

Still well worth a look for a fabulous dinner or lunch, particularly if you are looking to impress.

Mercy bar + eatery on Urbanspoon

Popular posts from this blog

The Lui Bar

In my opinion, some places are simply better experienced than described. This post features many photos which hardly do The Lui Bar (Level 55, Rialto Towers, 525 Collins Street, Melbourne) justice, because no matter how many pictures I show you or words I write about it, there is just nothing like viewing Melbourne from 55 floors up, handcrafted cocktail in hand, listening to jazz.

The Lui Bar stems off Shannon Bennett's revered restaurant Vue De Monde, the degustation meal of which is absolutely on my bucket list. The restaurant was moved to the Rialto site in 2011, and its adjoining bar has also been making waves ever since.

Iconic in location, the venue not only occupies the top level of what was, in 1986, the tallest building in Melbourne and the Southern Hemisphere at 251 metres, but offers spectacular city views of up to 60 kilometres on a clear day. Even the Eureka Tower, currently Melbourne's tallest building at 297.3 metres, looks smaller from the Rialto's former …

Steak Night and Pub Meal Specials

Want Melbourne Patron blog posts delivered straight to your inbox? Click on the "Subscribe" button at the top of this page and follow the simple instructions. Magic!

I am a sucker for a good steak, and lately, what with moving house and all the extra expenses that incurs, I've been on the lookout for great pub specials such as steak nights. I've been keeping a list on my phone of some of the deals I've found at venues around my home and work (mostly in the CBD, Fitzroy/Collingwood, Richmond/Abbotsford, South Yarra/Prahran/Windsor, South Melbourne) - and there are lots, so please note I haven't tried them all. Several of my friends have asked me to send them a copy of the list - so I figure this way, I can share it with everybody who might be interested!

PLEASE NOTE: This is by no means a comprehensive list of all the pub specials in Melbourne (there are many websites for that already!), nor is it necessarily current. I will do my best to keep it up-to-date - if…


Minamishima A Japanese den by a sushi master, hidden in Richmond 
If you're the sort that baulks at $150-per-head set menus, you'll never truly appreciate a place like Minamishima (4 Lord Street, Richmond).

Sure, it's got a price tag. But for foodie purists, every cent is worth it. You are not just paying for supreme-grade ingredients, some of which are regularly shipped in from a Tokyo fish market, prepared by world-class, highly skilled chefs, presented impeccably and all melt-in-your-mouth, oh-my-God orgasmic. You are paying for the anticipation. For the ever-filled water glass and replenished napkin. For the hushed, dramatic mood of the restaurant itself. For dishes timed to perfection, and the en-pointe realisation of your most specific drink requirements. You are paying for the entire experience.

In my opinion? It's better than a weekend away, which is hella more expensive.

Minamishima opened in October 2014 with no fanfare. Owner-chef Koichi Minamishima spent t…